How to Find Christian Friends as a New Believer

Joshua McFann

May 18, 2026

Finding Christian friends sounds simple—go to church, meet people, build community. But for a lot of people, it doesn’t actually work that way. You can show up every Sunday, shake hands, smile in the hallway, and still go home completely alone. If that’s where you are right now, this is for you. Real, life-giving Christian friendship is possible, and these five steps will help you start building it.

 

What I’ve Learned the Hard Way

I was so talkative in first grade that my teacher had to move my desk away from the other kids.

The only problem was every time she moved it, I made friends with the kids in that new area. So she moved it again. And I made friends there too.

It was a problem back then. Now, I just call it a gift.

But here’s the thing: I’m not writing this for people like me. I’m writing this for the person who sits in church every Sunday, goes home, and genuinely has no idea how to take it further than that. The person who knows they need community, believes they need community, and still somehow doesn’t have it.

I’ve actually experienced that, too, just a few years ago.

What Happens When You Don’t Have It

When I graduated high school—COVID year, a weird time for everyone—I walked straight into one of the loneliest seasons of my life. I got into a relationship that wasn’t healthy, and instead of letting my Christian community speak into that, I just cut them off entirely. Nobody was challenging me. Nobody was pointing me to Jesus. Nobody even knew what was going on.

So, I started spending time with people who had no connection to Jesus at all. And slowly, without even realizing it, my life started looking like theirs (Proverbs 13:20).

You’ve probably heard the phrase “Show me your five closest friends, and I’ll show you your future.” I used to think that was cheesy. Then I lived it.

That relationship turned abusive. It got dark. And the thing that pulled me out wasn’t a sermon or a book or a moment of personal clarity; it was a wedding.

A friend from my church invited me to be a groomsman. I hadn’t seen these people in almost a year. I showed up to the rehearsal dinner feeling like a stranger in a place that used to be home. I just stood there and watched the Body of Christ doing exactly what it’s supposed to do—loving each other, serving each other, and celebrating together (1 Corinthians 12:27). It was holy. And I didn’t have any of it.

Person after person came up to me that day and said some version of the same thing: I’ve missed you. I’ve been praying for you. I love you.

Something broke open inside of me. I thought, That’s it! That’s what I’ve been missing. That’s what I need.

I left that relationship, came back to my church, and what I found waiting for me was nothing but open arms.

Community didn’t just feel good; it saved my life.

 

Why Most People Don’t Have It

Before we get into the how, I want to say something specifically to my introverted friends because I know you’ve heard the “you need community” speech a hundred times and it hasn’t helped yet.

Here’s what I think is actually happening: most people don’t find community exhausting because they’re introverts. They find it exhausting because they’re around the wrong people. Strangers are hard, people who don’t think like you are hard, and awkward small talk is hard. Real community—people who are on the same mission, who get what you’re about, who you can actually be honest with—that’s a different thing entirely. That fills you up instead of draining you (Hebrews 10:24–25).

One of the wisest things I ever heard about this came from two women in my youth group named Andrea and Kerry. They were best friends and they had this concept called the marble jar. The idea is simple: some people put marbles in your jar by investing in you, encouraging you, and building you up. Some people take marbles out.

What they said that stuck with me was that it doesn’t matter how many people fill your jar. It just matters that somebody does. My wife can spend a full evening talking to one person and walk away just as full as I am after talking to 30. Neither of us is doing it wrong. Community is not one-size-fits-all.

But here’s the danger—if you only give marbles out, and nobody gives them back, your jar empties. When your jar is empty long enough, you start making choices you never thought you’d make. I’ve watched it happen to pastors. I’ve watched it happen to ordinary people. An empty jar is a serious thing.

 

5 Practical Steps for How to Find Christian Friends That Actually Work

Okay. Here’s the practical part: you want community, but you’re stuck on the ‘where’ and the ‘who.’ If you’re wondering how to find Christian friends who actually share your values, here’s what I’d tell you.

 

1. Start with prayer—real prayer. Not a passing thought; an actual sustained ask. When I came back to my church, one of the first things I did was pray specifically for men to come into my life. I prayed that for about six months. Slowly, one by one, men started showing up. One taught me how to grill a steak, and another asked me to go hiking. Those simple connections became the beginning of everything.

Pray specifically. Pray for boldness, and ask God for clarity on how to find Christian friends who will challenge and encourage you in this season. And if you already have a few names in your head—people you’d want to get to know—start praying for an open door with them by name (Philippians 4:6).

2. Take eight seconds of courage. That’s it. Eight seconds of uncomfortable. Walk up to someone and say, “I’d love to get coffee with you sometime.” You don’t need a long speech or a perfect moment. Sometimes the secret to how to find Christian friends isn’t a complex strategy; it’s just the willingness to be the first one to speak. The relationship that comes after might last decades. You genuinely have no idea what a skipped stone looks like 10 years down the road.

3. Ask them about their story. When you sit down with someone for coffee, lunch, whatever, just ask, “Tell me your story. How did you come to know Jesus and where are you at now?” People love being asked that question, and they’ll almost always ask it back. That one conversation can take you from strangers to something real faster than anything else I know.

4. Do something together. Some people aren’t great at just sitting and talking. That’s fine. Go disc golfing, go hiking, or maybe cook something together. Doing a thing side by side takes the pressure off and lets the conversation happen naturally. Remember that shared activities often build faster bonds than just sitting across a table. My buddy, Vince and I got to know each other way better on a disc golf course than we ever would have across a table.

5. Ask how you can pray for them. This is the move that goes from friendly to deep. Once you know someone a little, ask specifically how you can be praying for them, and then actually do it. The next time you see them, follow up: “Hey, I was praying for that thing you mentioned—how’s it going?” That’s not a technique; that’s just what it looks like to actually care about someone (James 5:16).

 

What If You Can’t Find Christian Community Near You?

Then start one.

I came back from a training program called Forge Equipping one summer with a burning heart, and nobody around me shared it. So, I did the only two things I was actually good at: I talked to people, and I made coffee. I texted everyone I knew and told them to come over Saturday morning at 8 a.m. for coffee, breakfast, and the Bible. That was the whole plan.

Five people showed up, then 10, then 20, and eventually 20 believers and five people who didn’t know Jesus yet sat in my living room, reading Scripture, asking real questions (Acts 2:42). I watched people give their lives to Jesus in that room; people who had never believed.

It didn’t require a budget or a plan or a title.

Sometimes the most effective way to solve the problem of how to find Christian friends is to simply be the one who opens the door first.

Maybe that someone is you.

And one more thing: if you’re telling yourself you’re too busy for this, I want to ask you an honest question. Are you actually busy, or do you just have four hours a night of scrolling that you’ve started calling rest? Real rest, the kind that actually refills you, usually involves another person: a phone call, a meal, even 15 minutes of real honesty and prayer with someone who knows you.

One hour a week. That’s all I’m asking.

You have no idea what it could become.

If you want to go deeper than Sunday attendance, to get equipped alongside other young adult believers who are serious about living for Jesus, Forge Equipping is a practical next step. It’s a hands-on program designed to help you grow from a new believer into someone who actively advances God’s Kingdom every day, everywhere.

 

Download the Full Infographic!